Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="LokiDR" data-source="post: 4380067" data-attributes="member: 6239">That isn't a question.&nbsp; The question is &quot;how long do I have until I am counted as failing to engage?&quot;In the simplest example, Bob challenges Mon then move adjacent to Mon then attacks.&nbsp; On Mon's turn, he attacks.&nbsp; Back to Bob, he decides to use a ranged power so he shifts back.&nbsp; At this point, he has failed to engage in the turn: he hasn't attacked and won't be adjacent at the end of the turn.You hand wave this by only checking for &quot;engaged&quot; at the end of the round.&nbsp; Why is that more correct than after every action?&nbsp; After all, only half of the definition of engage involves the end of the round.&nbsp; I say, for the choice to be truly meaningful, the first challenge must have the option to be replaced and that means you check engage OR target each turn.&nbsp; On the first turn you target, you changed your target from nothing.At this point, I think it's clear you aren't going to accept my point so there is little reason to post more.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="LokiDR, post: 4380067, member: 6239"] That isn't a question. The question is "how long do I have until I am counted as failing to engage?" In the simplest example, Bob challenges Mon then move adjacent to Mon then attacks. On Mon's turn, he attacks. Back to Bob, he decides to use a ranged power so he shifts back. At this point, he has failed to engage in the turn: he hasn't attacked and won't be adjacent at the end of the turn. You hand wave this by only checking for "engaged" at the end of the round. Why is that more correct than after every action? After all, only half of the definition of engage involves the end of the round. I say, for the choice to be truly meaningful, the first challenge must have the option to be replaced and that means you check engage OR target each turn. On the first turn you target, you changed your target from nothing. At this point, I think it's clear you aren't going to accept my point so there is little reason to post more. [/QUOTE]

Verification