Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hypersmurf" data-source="post: 4380670" data-attributes="member: 1656">Exactly.Because &quot;On your turn, you must engage your target or challenge a different target.&quot;At any point before the end of your turn, you still have a chance to do it &quot;on your turn&quot;.&nbsp; Once the end of your turn arrives, you no longer have a chance to fulfill either of those conditions &quot;on your turn&quot;.At the point where Bob shifts back, he has not yet engaged, but we won't know whether he has failed to engage on his turn until his turn is over.Now, instead of making a ranged attack on Mon, Bob now challenges Al.&nbsp; He has fulfilled the condition of the Challenge on Mon - on his turn, he either engaged Mon or challenged a different target.&nbsp; So the Challenge on Mon will not trigger the &quot;can't use DC next turn&quot; consequence.But he's just used Divine Challenge on Al, and Divine Challenge has a condition - &quot;On your turn, you must engage the target or challenge a different target.&quot;&nbsp; So on his turn - before the end of his turn - he must engage Al, or challenge a target different to Al.-Hyp.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hypersmurf, post: 4380670, member: 1656"] Exactly. Because "On your turn, you must engage your target or challenge a different target." At any point before the end of your turn, you still have a chance to do it "on your turn". Once the end of your turn arrives, you no longer have a chance to fulfill either of those conditions "on your turn". At the point where Bob shifts back, he has not yet engaged, but we won't know whether he has failed to engage [i]on his turn[/i] until his turn is over. Now, instead of making a ranged attack on Mon, Bob now challenges Al. He has fulfilled the condition of the Challenge on Mon - on his turn, he either engaged Mon or challenged a different target. So the Challenge on Mon will not trigger the "can't use DC next turn" consequence. But he's just used Divine Challenge on Al, and Divine Challenge has a condition - "On your turn, you must engage the target or challenge a different target." So on his turn - before the end of his turn - he must engage Al, or challenge a target different to Al. -Hyp. [/QUOTE]

Verification