DMG solution for the Harm spell

[Celtavian]

Re

Isollae,

My mistake, heal doesn't grant a save to undead. It will in our version.

 

[Gez]

Re: Re: Re: DMG solution for the Harm spell

I like that myself. A 100hp cap on both Harm and Heal. But now we are into house rules.

A hp cap can bring in some strangeness, though.

"As time pass, my magic seems to be going ever more powerful, however that of my cleric buddy seems to get ever less efficient. When our fighter was lying unconscious, he used to heal him so efficiently his spell even seemed to mend his armor, while nowaday our fighter's wounds are still half-open."

(Of course, you have the exact same trouble with the classical cure wounds spells.)

 

[hong]

Re: Re: Re: Re: DMG solution for the Harm spell

A hp cap can bring in some strangeness, though.

"As time pass, my magic seems to be going ever more powerful, however that of my cleric buddy seems to get ever less efficient. When our fighter was lying unconscious, he used to heal him so efficiently his spell even seemed to mend his armor, while nowaday our fighter's wounds are still half-open."

(Of course, you have the exact same trouble with the classical cure wounds spells.)

IMC, the spells work as follows:

- Cure light wounds heals 1d8 hp, + 1 per level of recipient, when cast on a creature with > 0 hp. It heals 1 pt when cast on a creature with 0 or negative hp.

- CMW heals 1d8 hp, + 2 per level of recipient, when cast on a creature with > 0 hp. It heals 2 pts when cast on a creature with 0 or negative hp.

- CSW is 3 pts, CCW is 4.

- Heal heals 8 hp per level of recipient.

- Harm does 1d8 points per caster level, touch attack, no save.

 

[Ravellion]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: DMG solution for the Harm spell

IMC, the spells work as follows:

- Cure light wounds heals 1d8 hp, + 1 per level of recipient, when cast on a creature with > 0 hp. It heals 1 pt when cast on a creature with 0 or negative hp.

- CMW heals 1d8 hp, + 2 per level of recipient, when cast on a creature with > 0 hp. It heals 2 pts when cast on a creature with 0 or negative hp.

- CSW is 3 pts, CCW is 4.

- Heal heals 8 hp per level of recipient.

- Harm does 1d8 points per caster level, touch attack, no save.

These ideas can be considered "nicked", by me.

I'll also beat you with a stick, so you won't tell anyone. Well actually, just because I feel like it.

Rav

 

[hong]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: DMG solution for the Harm spell

I'll also beat you with a stick, so you won't tell anyone. Well actually, just because I feel like it.

Rav

Hong "mood swings" Ooi

 

[Tom Cashel]

Then why isn't there an 8th level spell called Mass Harm?

Because that would be broken, of course.

 

[Tom Cashel]

Go here to join S.H.I.N.Y.--Save Harm In the New Year.