Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BoldItalic" data-source="post: 7175411" data-attributes="member: 6777052">The party were down on hp after the last skirmish, and Ignatio, Cleric of All Gods and None In Particular, started healing his comrades. When he came to Bobbles the Halfling Rogue, a voice from on high suddenly intervened.&quot;Rogues are chaotic and healing a non-lawful creature is non-lawful. Ignatio, you lose all your spells and powers until you atone.&quot;Bobbles quickly recited four paragraphs of rules from his copy of the Campaign Guide. &quot;I'm converting to Lawful,&quot; he announced.&quot;Very well, Ignatio can heal you but you lose all your Rogue class features until you atone.&quot;&quot;Deal. I'm back to full hp? Definite?&quot;&quot;Yes, you are healed.&quot;&quot;Okay. I lied about the alignment change. I'm still chaotic. I get to keep my class features.&quot;&quot;But lying is ...&quot;&quot;Chaotic. Yeah. Proves I'm still chaotic, doesn't it?&quot;&quot;Look, guys, this isn't ...&quot;&quot;Seems fair to me,&quot; remarked Fernleaf the Druid, &quot;Speaking as a Neutral, I have no preference for either players or DM. I'm quite impartial. Healing is a good act and I condone it. Stripping a player of his class features is an evil act. The DM is not playing to his alignment and is stripped of his powers until he atones by awarding 1000gp to each PC. This is my judgement.&quot;Good luck with the campaign ideas ...</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BoldItalic, post: 7175411, member: 6777052"] [COLOR="#0000FF"]The party were down on hp after the last skirmish, and Ignatio, Cleric of All Gods and None In Particular, started healing his comrades. When he came to Bobbles the Halfling Rogue, a voice from on high suddenly intervened. "Rogues are chaotic and healing a non-lawful creature is non-lawful. Ignatio, you lose all your spells and powers until you atone." Bobbles quickly recited four paragraphs of rules from his copy of the Campaign Guide. "I'm converting to Lawful," he announced. "Very well, Ignatio can heal you but you lose all your Rogue class features until you atone." "Deal. I'm back to full hp? Definite?" "Yes, you are healed." "Okay. I lied about the alignment change. I'm still chaotic. I get to keep my class features." "But lying is ..." "Chaotic. Yeah. Proves I'm still chaotic, doesn't it?" "Look, guys, this isn't ..." "Seems fair to me," remarked Fernleaf the Druid, "Speaking as a Neutral, I have no preference for either players or DM. I'm quite impartial. Healing is a [i]good[/i] act and I condone it. Stripping a player of his class features is an [i]evil[/i] act. The DM is not playing to his alignment and is stripped of his powers until he atones by awarding 1000gp to each PC. This is my judgement." [/COLOR] Good luck with the campaign ideas ... [/QUOTE]

Verification