Eladrin (High Elf) vs. Githyanki RM:UT Round 1 (One Day Only!)

[TerraDave]

Big difference in seeding in this one...still, I wonder if the Githyanki can't at least put a scare in the nee High Elves. I mean, I see the eladrin going far, but they are facing this:

 

[Mallus]

Despite Githyanki originating in one of my all-time favorite supplements, my vote is for the Eladrin. IMHO, Eladrin are Fae/Melniboneans/whoever-the-hell-Corum's-people-where done right in D&D.

 

[Jhaelen]

Big difference in seeding in this one...still, I wonder if the Githyanki can't at least put a scare in the nee High Elves. I mean, I see the eladrin going far, but they are facing this:

Yeah, but it's a voting for the best PC race. Githyanki are not a (good) pc race. Eladrin are (even if they have a silly name).

 

[the Jester]

Githyanki are awesome, but I like them as antagonists, not protagonists.

This exactly.

In fact, in several of these race-offs, my vote is predicated on this premise.

 

[StreamOfTheSky]

Big difference in seeding in this one...still, I wonder if the Githyanki can't at least put a scare in the nee High Elves. I mean, I see the eladrin going far, but they are facing this:

...A wrinkly, elderly former prostitute swinging around a toy light up sword she bought for her kid at Toys R Us?