Encounter contest entry (Heat 1) - Feedback wanted

[tenelo]

Hi guys.

I went on holiday to a gaming convention in Ireland just before voting closed on heat one, which I had an entry in.

It was Harmonies in the Snow, and came 4th. Having only just got back, (really cool convention, but exhausting) I've missed all chance to comment in time. Would anybody of the 80ish people who voted in heat one give me some feedback on what you liked, what you didn't, why you did/didn't vote for Harmonies or something else?

And as an open question for the BADD webmaster, would a full write up of Faldorwinion the Bardic Faerie Dragon be suitable material for the website?

Cheers in advance,

Tenelo

 

[tenelo]

Was it really that boring?

Bump!

...at least half a dozen of you voted for it...

I've got several further bits of material I'd like to put with the location and NPC and make available somewhere, but if there's absolutely no interest then I'll only use them in my campaign rather than throwing them out into the wide world to clutter it up further.

 

[tenelo]

bump

 

[Berandor]

This is my original comment:

5. Harmonies in the snow.
That one almost got my vote!
A bardic pseudodragon, and a singing valley? I really liked both, but I found some of the explanations and bindings to be a bitt abrupt or confusing.
I will use this in my campaign, though, nevertheless.

More to come soon

 

[Quickbeam]

I enjoyed the concept of the Haunted Valley being inhabited by a good creature that possessed no ill will towards the outer world. Your encounter was in my top three, but ultimately I voted for an encounter that I felt would be more suitable to the preferences of my group.

There really wasn't anything about your entry that I didn't like, I just enjoyed another concept a wee bit more .