[ENnies] Three questions for everyone

Mark CMG · Feb 17, 2003

fusangite said:
Let's suppose, under your model, there are ten hypothetical candidates...

Your model is broken right there since this is not the case. That's why the poll is being used.

Umbran · Feb 17, 2003

fusangite said:
What belief system does your system of choosing judges represent? Myturnism? Newbyism? Tokenism? What principle is so important that it can trump democracy?

The same one that puts term limits on US Presidents, Fungusite. The idea that some positions should not rest in one set of hands forever.

Democracy is based upon the idea that an informed public can make good choices. To be informed, the appropriate ideas and information must be presented. By your incessant insulting and belittling, you show yourself to be against the informative process, and thus against a real democracy.

Think for a moment, fungusite - if your democracy cannot win the day in reasonable discussion, does it deserve to win? Your position should be strong enough to win without such tactics, fungusite. Can't you manage to discuss this without being rude?

Morrus · Feb 17, 2003

OK, that's enough. Name calling and childish sniping are not OK here. Thread closed.

[ENnies] Three questions for everyone

[ENnies] Three questions for everyone

1A It would be nice to have a policy to assure that at least one member of the committee is a new bl

1B It would be nice to have a policy to assure that at least two members of the committee are new bl

1C It would be nice to have a policy to assure that at least three members of the committee are new

1D It would be nice to have a policy to assure that at least four members of the committee are new b

1E It would be nice to have a policy to assure that all members of the committee are new blood candi

1F Let the chips fall where they may even if all members wind up being people who have previously se

2A Like professional publishers, professional reviewers should only be voters and not committee memb

2B It would be nice if the entire panel was comprised of professional reviewers making this closer t

2C The blend of professional reviewers and regular fans makes for a good mix for the committee.

3A The presence of WotC in the running for the ENnies skews the results beyond satisfaction and they

3B Only publishers who produce products under the OGL and d20 System license should be in the runnin

3C There should be some limits placed on WotC participation in the ENnies given their overwhelming p

3D There should be some limits placed on WotC and any publishers who have additional licensing agree

3E There should be no restrictions on WotC or any publisher as a contestant for ENnies awards as lon

Mark CMG

Creative Mountain Games

Umbran

Mod Squad

Morrus

Well, that was fun

Similar Threads