D&D 5E Extra Attack +1 feat

No. This steals a class feature.
I would say that this is not necessarily an issue, depending on how one looks at their game. For me personally... gaining an ability that is the same as another class's is not a problem if there isn't a person at the table playing that class (and thus not have to worry about stepping on toes). So for instance, if no one is playing a Monk in a particular campaign, I wouldn't have an issue if a player wanted to create a Feat for their 4th level selection that duplicated the functionality of a Monk class feature of an equal or lower level-- like if someone wanted the have Deflect Missiles for instance because it really added to their character and its concept. To my mind, this would be a one-off decision that just works for this one isolated character in this one isolated game, and thus I'm good with it. But I'm not going to add this special dispensation to my sheet of house-rules for the future so that others can take it themselves in subsequent campaigns.

But this is why I say it depends on how folks look at their game, because I'm fairly certain that there are DMs out there who want a consistency to their game and world and would believe that any rule like this they allowed in one game must now be a rule they allow in all subsequent games. I'm sure for them the rules define the reality and to just arbitrarily make up rules to then throw away when you're done is not what they look for in a system. Which I totally respect. But it does make it such that we can't call it a black or white issue. Using other class's features might work for some, but not for others. And each DM will need to determine it for themselves.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Wow, never needed Resilient? That's impressive. After my first fight with an enemy that I needed to roll a 19 on a save against it's effect (dragon fear), I realized my Fighter really should have Wis saves proficient.

Con is an equally good save, made better due to concentration for spellcasters.
I play a lot of casters, usually I like to get Wis proficiency.

Constitution is meh IME. If I lose concentration I will just cast the spell again. I find being smart in combat is generally better than having a good con save and it is rare that I want to boost con over an ASI or a half feat that boosts my casting ability. I actually find I miss dex more than I miss con on most casters I play, but not enough to take resilient.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top