Feat Ban/Change

[Heckler]

I'm thinking Merciful is a bit weaker, as it is still suceptable to resistances.

 

[Velmont]

I'm thinking Merciful is a bit weaker, as it is still suceptable to resistances.

Merciful can be applied to some spell that subdual couldn't. Examples: Spiritual Weapons, Magic Missiles, Vampiric Touch (In that case, it would probably heal subdual damage only) to name only them.

 

[Rystil Arden]

That guy Knight Otu quoted seemed to make a pretty good argument--I'm not sure I could find any flaws in his logic this time, and I generally trust him with game balance decisions, so let me add another redundant YES.

 

[Knight Otu]

I vote YES to the first three, but I'm not sure what you mean by the fourth. Updates meaning, erratta? Or like the Complete Divine being added to the SRD as a separate section, for some mysterious reason? If it's the latter, I agree with you; if it's the former, I don't.

The latter. That way, we don't suddenly wake up to an Enworld with Warforged Soulborns, Goliath Truenamers, Neanderthal Samurai and Illumian Binder/Favored Soul/Divine Mind/Knight...s if the unlikely should happen.

(Though I should note that I'm not necessarily against adding some of the mentioned elements in the unlikely case they do become open. But not everything.)

 

[Erekose13]

yeah all that should go through proposals like the Unearthed stuff should more be added to the SRD

 

[Knight Otu]

Merciful can be applied to some spell that subdual couldn't. Examples: Spiritual Weapons, Magic Missiles, Vampiric Touch (In that case, it would probably heal subdual damage only) to name only them.

Merciful Spell is for knocking out people with a mercyful blade barrier, Subdual Substitution is for knocking out red dragons with a subdual fireball?

 

[Patlin]

I'm late, and this is all aproved allready after the 48 hours, but for the record I'd vote No to 1 and 2 but Yes to 3 and 4.

However, as I said, this is allready all aproved.