CapnZapp
Legend
Thank you.Thanks for stating your goal, that makes it easy to evaluate in that context.
I think this works well. A few questions or comments but overall I'm positive to this.
Reduced analysis paralysis...? You're right, if there aren't any actual non-corner cases it can be removed.What is the purpose of being able to spend every other level?
Class level yes indeed.I'm assuming that's even class level
To be honest I don't think Rogues are so good, so I didn't bother complicating things.Rogues get less and slower bonus ASI then fighters, would it make sense to have them get a bonus on a level divided by three?
True.This seems a big boon to multiclassing, since they lose nothing not aiming for ASI levels - as a matter of fact except for spellcasters since ASI levels are now dead it encourages cherry-picking 1-3 levels. This I'd want to address somehow.
Technically you should gain 4 feat points every four class levels. Or only be allowed to spend feat points at certain levels.
But to be frank, that would kill the elegance - it would make the whole houserule fall apart IMO.
I don't have a solution. Maybe accept that if this change in multiclassing is unacceptable to a certain DM this houserule might not be right for him or her. To other DMs this is not a bug - in fact, to some DMs it is a desirable fix (not that I intended it as such).