Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="hong" data-source="post: 128942" data-attributes="member: 537">Yeah, yeah, that's what they ALL say.Yeah, yeah, that's what they ALL say.Make up your mind. Do you want to &quot;finish&quot; the war, or do you want not to &quot;react&quot;?Only to those who have got lost in the labyrinthine passages of the rulebooks, and strained their brain cells as a result.Is there a point to this, or is it just more stream-of-consciousness posting on your part?Chapter and verse, please. Cite _exactly where_ feeblemind is supposed to mimic disrupting concentration for casting spells.But of course, you can't. This is an extrapolation on _your_ part regarding the spell's internal processes, and one that isn't based on the spell description as given. Whether or not it's a reasonable extrapolation, or one that's balanced, is beside the point. The point is that, _as written_, feeblemind does not affect spell-like abilities, and there's no reason to suppose otherwise. The fact that you're having to resort to muddying the difference between spell-like abilities and actual spells should be a clue to this.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="hong, post: 128942, member: 537"] Yeah, yeah, that's what they ALL say. Yeah, yeah, that's what they ALL say. Make up your mind. Do you want to "finish" the war, or do you want not to "react"? Only to those who have got lost in the labyrinthine passages of the rulebooks, and strained their brain cells as a result. Is there a point to this, or is it just more stream-of-consciousness posting on your part? Chapter and verse, please. Cite _exactly where_ feeblemind is supposed to mimic disrupting concentration for casting spells. But of course, you can't. This is an extrapolation on _your_ part regarding the spell's internal processes, and one that isn't based on the spell description as given. Whether or not it's a reasonable extrapolation, or one that's balanced, is beside the point. The point is that, _as written_, feeblemind does not affect spell-like abilities, and there's no reason to suppose otherwise. The fact that you're having to resort to muddying the difference between spell-like abilities and actual spells should be a clue to this. [/QUOTE]

Verification