Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="MechaTarrasque" data-source="post: 8563336" data-attributes="member: 6801226">I treat alignment as what the PC or NPC is at a given moment.&nbsp; I look at the law and chaos axis to be mostly about how you want other people to perceive you.&nbsp; Lawful and chaotic types both want others to notice them (for different reasons).&nbsp; Neutrals would prefer that others didn't think about them too much (for example Yugoloths don't want you to think about how easy it is to bribe them, because you wouldn't hire them, but they don't want you to think they are hard to bribe either).&nbsp; The PC trying to sneak into a castle is probably some kind of neutral while the sneaking is going on.Lawful types are interested in demonstrating themselves as respectable.&nbsp; The people (or things) that they want to see them as respectable may not be on hand (&quot;tell my parents back in the village I died well&quot;) but they are in the head of the lawful types.&nbsp; If lawful types want to fit in, chaotic types want to stand out.&nbsp; Maybe you annoyed someone, inspired them, or terrified them.&nbsp; When I run chaotic evil NPC's, they always try to leave one survivor to spread the legend of their cruel deeds (I have even had a young red dragon follow his survivor [at a distance] and save him from trolls so the witness could tell everyone how great and terrible the dragon was).Good and evil is a little harder given that many players want their PC's to kill their enemies and steal their stuff with the thin fig leaf of &quot;the enemies are monsters or evil&quot; while not having evil on the character sheet.&nbsp; That leaves out a lot of traditional definitions.&nbsp; So, I focus on sadism:&nbsp; if you do something bad to someone or something but it is &quot;just business&quot;, you are neutral; if you enjoyed it, you are evil; and if you feel bad about it, you are probably good.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="MechaTarrasque, post: 8563336, member: 6801226"] I treat alignment as what the PC or NPC is at a given moment. I look at the law and chaos axis to be mostly about how you want other people to perceive you. Lawful and chaotic types both want others to notice them (for different reasons). Neutrals would prefer that others didn't think about them too much (for example Yugoloths don't want you to think about how easy it is to bribe them, because you wouldn't hire them, but they don't want you to think they are hard to bribe either). The PC trying to sneak into a castle is probably some kind of neutral while the sneaking is going on. Lawful types are interested in demonstrating themselves as respectable. The people (or things) that they want to see them as respectable may not be on hand ("tell my parents back in the village I died well") but they are in the head of the lawful types. If lawful types want to fit in, chaotic types want to stand out. Maybe you annoyed someone, inspired them, or terrified them. When I run chaotic evil NPC's, they always try to leave one survivor to spread the legend of their cruel deeds (I have even had a young red dragon follow his survivor [at a distance] and save him from trolls so the witness could tell everyone how great and terrible the dragon was). Good and evil is a little harder given that many players want their PC's to kill their enemies and steal their stuff with the thin fig leaf of "the enemies are monsters or evil" while not having evil on the character sheet. That leaves out a lot of traditional definitions. So, I focus on sadism: if you do something bad to someone or something but it is "just business", you are neutral; if you enjoyed it, you are evil; and if you feel bad about it, you are probably good. [/QUOTE]

Verification