Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Mistwell" data-source="post: 9098749" data-attributes="member: 2525">False premise. What was said was, &quot;I am sure one of the key questions that they have tried to assess is &quot;are old 3e/4e players happier now than they were with the older systems?&quot; And I'm pretty sure the answer on the whole is yes.&quot;He's right that they are definitely surveying on which system you started playing D&amp;D and tying that to the results of surveys so this is specifically something they ask every time. There was nothing about what he said which doesn't also encompass &quot;that other system or edition [guards against similar problems.]&quot; IF the player who liked system X is even more satisfied now with system Y, then it's fair to say the things system X did might in fact not be viewed as superior to system Y. It was not a dismissal, he's directly answering the challenge you posed.Bottom line: you're talking past each other, dismissing his opinion as if it were a dismissal of yours, rather than directly answering the premise he poses with his answer.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Mistwell, post: 9098749, member: 2525"] False premise. What was said was, "I am sure one of the key questions that they have tried to assess is "are old 3e/4e players happier now than they were with the older systems?" And I'm pretty sure the answer on the whole is yes." He's right that they are definitely surveying on which system you started playing D&D and tying that to the results of surveys so this is specifically something they ask every time. There was nothing about what he said which doesn't also encompass "that other system or edition [guards against similar problems.]" IF the player who liked system X is even more satisfied now with system Y, then it's fair to say the things system X did might in fact not be viewed as superior to system Y. It was not a dismissal, he's directly answering the challenge you posed. Bottom line: you're talking past each other, dismissing his opinion as if it were a dismissal of yours, rather than directly answering the premise he poses with his answer. [/QUOTE]

Verification