Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="iserith" data-source="post: 8099698" data-attributes="member: 97077">The rules aren't perfect. They contain errors, hence why they've put forward errata. Clearly they haven't captured all of it. The questions then become: Is the entire section on hiding in combination with certain rules in the combat chapter wrong? Or is it just second paragraph of the ranger's feral sense ability that is wrong? The answer is obvious in my view, particularly as the designers have endorsed the entire section on hiding and how that works quite clearly as it relates to invisibility.I think most people not trying to win an argument about this specific topic and who are just trying to examine feral senses on its own reach will also tend to reach the conclusion that the second paragraph of the ranger ability is badly written and can be disregarded. Feel free to google such discussions to see for yourself. The consensus is clear that the second paragraph of feral senses doesn't make any, well, sense.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="iserith, post: 8099698, member: 97077"] The rules aren't perfect. They contain errors, hence why they've put forward errata. Clearly they haven't captured all of it. The questions then become: Is the entire section on hiding in combination with certain rules in the combat chapter wrong? Or is it just second paragraph of the ranger's feral sense ability that is wrong? The answer is obvious in my view, particularly as the designers have endorsed the entire section on hiding and how that works quite clearly as it relates to invisibility. I think most people not trying to win an argument about this specific topic and who are just trying to examine feral senses on its own reach will also tend to reach the conclusion that the second paragraph of the ranger ability is badly written and can be disregarded. Feel free to google such discussions to see for yourself. The consensus is clear that the second paragraph of feral senses doesn't make any, well, [I]sense.[/I] [/QUOTE]

Verification