D&D 5E HELP! deciding between stories

[jayoungr]

Frankly, they all sound good to me; I hope that doing one doesn't mean you'll discard the other ideas!

I'm going to put in a word for #1. Its biggest weakness is also its biggest strength--namely, that it's a straightforward mission. It might be called generic, but that also means it's adaptable to almost any group and can easily be dropped into someone's homebrew game world.

I also like #2 (interesting opportunities for roleplay and investigation) and #4 (could be nicely creepy with all the undead and revenge).

 

[DM_Jeff]

#3, just sounds like there would be lots of juice moral dilemmas.

#2 and #4 as runner-ups, in that order.

 

[Sunseeker]

I agree that #2 sounds the best and simplest to cover within a short amount of game time. And arguably dealing with the fey is both irritating and entertaining.