It is silly both because of the DM and because of the players. This is her first time DMing, so she's a little crazy with the whole concept of "Wheeeeeeeeeee."
Let's see... my Fire Elemental Barbarian, named George, is fascinated by water, but repulsed by it. Tonight, he ended up with a pearl that allows him to cast Create Water 3 times per day. First thing he did was drench the Holyphant. He's smart for a Fire Elemental (6 Int) and stays in the oven at Inns. His first adventure started with him in a bar getting a drink. He didn't like the beer (too watery), but loved the chaser (something akin to paint thinner called Dragon's Breath). He scorched the poor bartender when he belched. They've picked up some Skumble (Terry Prachett drink however it's spelled), which he really likes. Also, he regularly demands cookies from the Holyphant. The Holyphant did pick up some charcoal briquets for cookies for George, but ocassionally forgets and begrudgingly gives up one of his own cookies.