Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ultimatecalibur" data-source="post: 5493990" data-attributes="member: 59539">Ugh, Danny, please stop. You are using fallacious arguments, primarily a variation of the &quot;No true Scotsman&quot; fallacy, irrelevant conclusions, and begging the question.The point being is that while Batman's race is &quot;normal&quot; human, just like Superman's race is &quot;Kryptonian&quot; and the Flash's is &quot;Speedster,&quot; he is still a superhero. They all solve problems in ways that are beyond what real people can reasonably do. If a sniper shoots a bullet at a one of them: Superman catches the bullet with his superspeed, the Flash dodges it after the shot is fired, and Batman already new about the sniper and set it up so that the sniper could not make the shot for various reasons. They handle the bomb problem in a similar way: Superman survives by his invulnerability, the FLash outruns the blast and Batman dives into a nearby safe and rides out the blast in a way that would kill a real person but comes out unharmed.One of Batman's, and also Sherlock Holmes', &quot;superpowers&quot; is to make those kinds of deductions. No one else can really make those deductions because they don't have the &quot;World's Greatest Detective&quot; class. Your average thug with kryponite weaponry would not make those deductions or have the ability to act on them, only Batman and those with similar skills can and do.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ultimatecalibur, post: 5493990, member: 59539"] Ugh, Danny, please stop. You are using fallacious arguments, primarily a variation of the "No true Scotsman" fallacy, irrelevant conclusions, and begging the question. The point being is that while Batman's race is "normal" human, just like Superman's race is "Kryptonian" and the Flash's is "Speedster," he is still a superhero. They all solve problems in ways that are beyond what real people can reasonably do. If a sniper shoots a bullet at a one of them: Superman catches the bullet with his superspeed, the Flash dodges it after the shot is fired, and Batman already new about the sniper and set it up so that the sniper could not make the shot for various reasons. They handle the bomb problem in a similar way: Superman survives by his invulnerability, the FLash outruns the blast and Batman dives into a nearby safe and rides out the blast in a way that would kill a real person but comes out unharmed. One of Batman's, and also Sherlock Holmes', "superpowers" is to make those kinds of deductions. No one else can really make those deductions because they don't have the "World's Greatest Detective" class. Your average thug with kryponite weaponry would not make those deductions or have the ability to act on them, only Batman and those with similar skills can and do. [/QUOTE]

Verification