Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Ruin Explorer" data-source="post: 8286507" data-attributes="member: 18">These are good suggestions for the X+1 approach. Only things I'd change would be:1) Ditch Assassin for Mastermind. Assassin is just such a mean trap, I've see two players pick it and be dissatisfied with it IRL alone - online I've seen far more of that. If you want &quot;Killer Rogue&quot; Swashbuckler is better in every way. Assassin is just a lie of a name. He should be called like &quot;Disguise-murder-failure&quot; or something. I'd say &quot;Hitman Codename: D&amp;D&quot; but he's nowhere NEAR competent enough (at any level) to model Hitman Codename 47's Hitman. Literally a bunch of other Rogue subtypes would do better 47s.2) Totally personal but I'd drop Fey Wanderer for Beeeeeeesmaster aka Swarm Ranger. Realistically though there's no way they'd give Rangers less archetypes than Fighters or Paladins, so I'd keep your layout but add &quot;Oh god the bees!&quot;.3) Ditch Cavalier just because it's so badly designed and fails to achieve any of the things a person who selects as class named &quot;Cavalier&quot; wants, instead achieving the things a class called something like &quot;Shieldmaster&quot; or &quot;Protector&quot; might offer. I'd take Samurai and rename it to &quot;Knight&quot; or something instead.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Ruin Explorer, post: 8286507, member: 18"] These are good suggestions for the X+1 approach. Only things I'd change would be: 1) Ditch Assassin for Mastermind. Assassin is just such a mean trap, I've see two players pick it and be dissatisfied with it IRL alone - online I've seen far more of that. If you want "Killer Rogue" Swashbuckler is better in every way. Assassin is just a lie of a name. He should be called like "Disguise-murder-failure" or something. I'd say "Hitman Codename: D&D" but he's nowhere NEAR competent enough (at any level) to model Hitman Codename 47's Hitman. Literally a bunch of other Rogue subtypes would do better 47s. 2) Totally personal but I'd drop Fey Wanderer for Beeeeeeesmaster aka Swarm Ranger. Realistically though there's no way they'd give Rangers less archetypes than Fighters or Paladins, so I'd keep your layout but add "Oh god the bees!". 3) Ditch Cavalier just because it's so badly designed and fails to achieve any of the things a person who selects as class named "Cavalier" wants, instead achieving the things a class called something like "Shieldmaster" or "Protector" might offer. I'd take Samurai and rename it to "Knight" or something instead. [/QUOTE]

Verification