Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Lyxen" data-source="post: 8588537" data-attributes="member: 7032025">Prove that it's a change. Prove that, in the D&D world, according to the rules, the air is made of O2 and N2 rather than elemental air. I'm sure you will find this very difficult since the game, rightly, leaves that question open.From the rules actually, the only ones on this subject. "Instantaneous" is a term used for spells, and the definition is as follows:[ATTACH=full]154566[/ATTACH]After the disappearance.Prove it. Where is it said in the rules.And that includes the disappearance, THEN the boom at the very least, showing that there can be a sequence of events in an instant.Cool, does it say anything about the timing ?No, the boom occurs after the disappearance.Again, read the spell, appearance and disappearance are discussed separately on two occasions.And that is EXACTLY my point. If you want the appearance to be simultaneous with the disappearance, you can do so, but it I want the appearance to be after the boom, I can do so as well.... After what ? After the disappearance, not after the teleportation, not after the appearance. It is VERY specific.Indeed, but after what ? The problem is that, as some other people you infer that the appearance needs to be absolutely simultaneous with the disapperance, but NOTHING says so in the description. Nor in any teleportation spell, actually, they only say that the overall teleportation happens in an instant, not in 0 time.Both interpretations are valid, which is why people should not try to shoot down the other point of view. It's as valid as theirs, even if it requires thinking differently.</blockquote>

Verification