Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Infiniti2000" data-source="post: 3212710" data-attributes="member: 31734">So, are you suggesting that the single paragraph on Two-Weapon Fighting refers to two different scenarios?  I.e. one of them is the full attack action "fighting this way" and the other is the which-weapons-are-readied "fighting this way"?  From my reading, "fighting this way" can only occur if an extra attack per round is gained.  If that extra attack is not gained, then the remainder of the paragraph is not used, thus you are not "fighting this way." Well, I'd agree, but it depends on how the DM rules when a weapon is wielded or not, in actual practice.  In the withdraw example, the DM has to force the player to answer a question on which weapon(s) are wielded and which are just held, according your interpretation, right?  I suppose you could establish a default or something, but nevertheless it's more 'bookkeeping' to some degree. That doesn't answer the question.  Can I make an attack of opportunity or not?  I think Hyp's interpretation is yes, but with TWF penalties.</blockquote>