Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Mustrum_Ridcully" data-source="post: 3978633" data-attributes="member: 710">While I will not deny that your example might have some merit on its own, it doesn't fit this topic.If I remember correctly, the article doesn't claim that 1E was stupid and should be forgotten, DMs then where lazy and used all the same stories or whatever else negative one could make up about 1E. The context was explaining what the PoL and the fluff in the 4E is, comparing it to 1E implied setting. Even if his example wasn't entirely correct (since the core rules apparently did not make the implications about Gruumsh Eyes), it's unreasonable to interpret bad will into it. In fact, if anyone tried to do this with a quote from a poster on this board, I think he would at least be pretty close to violating our forum rules. (Which at least makes it questionable, though I am not saying it would be outright wrong to do so with external sources.)</blockquote>