Darrin Drader
Explorer
Odd, I was going to comment on that thread, and I had already mentioned the smell, but then decided to trash my comments since I didn't actually arrive at a pro- or con- decision. But yeah, add me to the group of weirdos who love the smell of the old AD&D books. And as sad as this sounds, I actually opened up my DMG today to see if that old smell still lingered, and though the paper is just a tad more yellow than I remember, the smell remains. Aaaaah!