Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Fast Learner" data-source="post: 5173789" data-attributes="member: 649">It depends on which Claire yelling he's talking about. She was definitely yelling in horror/frustration in response to Locke/Smokey reporting that the sub had sunk and implying that indeed some of them were dead.Here's my understanding: Smokey can't kill candidates, but candidates can certainly be killed by others. That's Jack's idea behind the bomb: if Sawyer had left it alone then it couldn't have killed any of them, but if it was messed with then it would be Sawyer killing them, which is exactly what happened.They're not the same as Richard, but they are protected from Smokey.</blockquote>