Upgrade your account to a Community Supporter account and remove most of the site ads.
Rocket your D&D 5E and Level Up: Advanced 5E games into space! Alpha Star Magazine Is Launching... Right Now!

Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="AbdulAlhazred" data-source="post: 5847210" data-attributes="member: 82106">Well, it long predates the video game industry of course. I can attest that in the very earliest adventures in the days before days (or at least before the first module) there were plenty of magic items being given out. I think the thing is it is easy to talk about amazingly cool games where the magic is magic, the barbarians are all mighty thewed heroes with a great backstory, and the women are all... Er, em, where was I. The truth is that most DMs are not incredible story tellers. We're just ordinary mortals and playing a fun casual game where if we're lucky the campaign goes somewhere and most of it is about instant gratification and fun moments. Handing out some magic items is a cool and easy way to have some fun and move things along. Yeah, it isn't exactly highbrow literary quality fantasy epic, but it is FUN.Thus the game really mostly is designed to cater to the common man amongst gamers. In fact this probably explains the success of D&D specifically through the years more than anything else. It's a very accessible game. Most ordinary people, like me, can whip up an adventure that consists of a plot hook or two, a fairly simple map, some basic monsters, and a pile of treasure or two. On our more inspired days we come up with a pretty cliche NPC and some reasonably cunning traps. I've DMed for basically ever and I'll be totally honest, that's really the root of my being successful, to some degree, as a DM. In the final analysis the people designing a new version of D&D have to ask themselves some questions. The main one being what segment of the audience is it most important to support and to what degree does that need to shape the way the game works? IMHO for most DMs and groups a game that easily slots in all the magic items they're going to be handed anyway seems like a pretty solid choice to make. Sure, that means items are basically assumed, but it also means the average DM has a fairly easy time running the game. If it can be done in such a way that the game also supports the amazing tales of the Piratecat's of the world that's great. Most of us just aren't in that league and such options probably won't help us a lot.At the end of a hard-fought battle when my players are eagerly expecting treasure and cool lootz and getting ready to tote up their XP totals and see if they went up a level yet a few magical items that they can use in the next adventure and do something cool, albeit even if it is just add to a die roll they make often, that meets the need. I'd be kind of surprised if 5e wasn't aimed largely at that kind of DM and game. I know it probably would be if I were in charge. I'd really strongly favor a design that allows for the rare unique story-item-only mode of play as well. Honestly though is 4e not pretty much that game? It certainly is much more so than 3.x is from what I can see. You have a relatively simple official option in the book that supports getting rid of any mechanical dependency and really the rest is always going to be up to the DM. Given that such games are run by people who have a pretty thorough understanding of the game, generally, I'd be most likely in favor of making really low magic the option and making classic D&D magic-is-common the default option. Maybe there's a cleaner way to do it than 4e did, but I'm hard-pressed to see what it is.</blockquote>

Verification