MerricB Has Reviewed a Bunch of 3rd-Party D&D 5E Products! And One Old One!

Despite the lack of a license, the third-party market for D&D 5E stuff is growing - an adventures seem particularly popular. MerricB (long time EN World member and blogger) has taken it upon himself to review these products as they come out. I've listed the reviews and his short comments, below, but click through for the full reviews plus a bonus scathing review of the old D&D adventure Quagmire! from back in 1984.

The Temple of Qultar by Chubby Monster Games -- Short site-based adventure with good flavour.

DG1: Secrets in the Dark by Dan Hass Endeavors -- Two foes ally with each other in a short, mostly linear adventure.

DG2 - The Lost Tome by Dan Hass Endeavors -- Simple adventure around the quest for a book.

DG3: The Archaeologist -- A noble needs help (but beware his previous "help"!)

DG4: And the Elf Prince Wept -- Promising beginning of a war-based adventure arc.

M1: An Echo of Days Past: A Storm About To Break by Arcadian Games-- Ambitious 99-page adventure set on the frontier lands of an expanding kingdom.

Merric also reviews old D&D adventures, and recently took on Quagmire! which he thinks is awful: "People talk about bad adventures like The Forest Oracle because they’re at least interesting in how they go wrong. No-one talks about Quagmire! because it’s just dull. The main hook for the adventure doesn’t work, and though there is some attempt at more detailed wilderness exploration, the results are hardly worth the effort. This is one of the worst adventures I’ve read in the line."

17100.jpg




 

log in or register to remove this ad

[MENTION=3586]MerricB[/MENTION], are you going to update this thread as you review new adventures or should I check your blog? Very useful either way.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Easier just to check the blog, I think.

It's been a strange week - I've been so busy with other things, I haven't been able to update the blog, but neither have I noticed any new 5E adventures coming out. (A couple appeared on DriveThru, but both are multi-system without stats, so I don't include those).

Cheers!
 

Remove ads

Remove ads

Top