Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 4234432" data-attributes="member: 22779">Look, I'm not bagging on 3e.&nbsp; I'm not saying 3e is bad at all.&nbsp; What I AM saying, is that by RAW, you cannot do what they are doing in 4e.&nbsp; YES YOU CAN DO IT BY IGNORING THE RULES.I shouted that so no one would say that I'm ignoring that fact.&nbsp; But, that's not what I'm arguing.&nbsp; I'm arguing, BY RAW, you cannot do minions.&nbsp; They break several 3e RAW rules.&nbsp; And, Andor and Storm Bringer, I know that you agree with me here because you admit to such.&nbsp; The fact that you have to invoke Rule 0 (which doesn't exactly say what you think it says in 3e) in order to do it shows you know I'm right.Can you have 1 hp baddies in 3e?&nbsp; By RAW, no.&nbsp; By DM changing the rules - yes.&nbsp; However, if you are changing the rules to get what you want, isn't that the same thing as having rules in place that give you what you want?</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 4234432, member: 22779"] Look, I'm not bagging on 3e. I'm not saying 3e is bad at all. What I AM saying, is that by RAW, you cannot do what they are doing in 4e. YES YOU CAN DO IT BY IGNORING THE RULES. I shouted that so no one would say that I'm ignoring that fact. But, that's not what I'm arguing. I'm arguing, BY RAW, you cannot do minions. They break several 3e RAW rules. And, Andor and Storm Bringer, I know that you agree with me here because you admit to such. The fact that you have to invoke Rule 0 (which doesn't exactly say what you think it says in 3e) in order to do it shows you know I'm right. Can you have 1 hp baddies in 3e? By RAW, no. By DM changing the rules - yes. However, if you are changing the rules to get what you want, isn't that the same thing as having rules in place that give you what you want? [/QUOTE]

Verification