Nyeshet
First Post
I roll to disbelieve.Shemeska said:like walking into a 20x50 room and *rolling dice* encountering 1d4 demogorgons.

I also tend to roll the treasure first, although sometimes I'll have the treasure all together elsewhere. That is, if a small tribe of evil goblins were raiding a town, the best the party may get out of defeating a few scouts or sentries is their small sized weapons / armor, their rations, perhaps a whetstone and oil, etc. But once they defeated them main bandit / goblin encampment they would likely find several nice (albeit small) chests inside the headman's tent - with money, potions, perhaps a few minor magic items, etc - in worth equal to the majority of treasure for all the goblin encounters experienced since the quest began.
If the encounter is small and not part of a greater whole I would roll treasure first. Otherwise, I would determine the likely treasure of the entire group and divy it out a small part of it amongst the various ones likely to have it - generally the higher ranking ones, and they will make use of it if allowed the chance.