CapnZapp
Legend
In theory I see your point.But again [MENTION=12731]CapnZapp[/MENTION] if those scouts *did* have "good" stats, they could overshadow the PCs.
Sent from my SM-G930W8 using EN World mobile app
But in practice I'm having great trouble seeing it. The Scout NPC is decidedly low-level, in some cases outshone even by level 1 characters.
And in general, you have to work *very* hard to find NPCs equal to player characters at any tier of the game.
Sure it's possible to have a CR 9 Champion accompany a third level party, but that's light years from what's happening in practice.
In other words, there is a space between hopelessly squishy Scouts and, say, the Warlord from Volo's. A very large space, I might add.
You can't argue "either Scouts or its overshadowing". Not when the party is level 8 (as in this OotA example).
Sent from my C6603 using EN World mobile app