My God, It's Full of Clones

pawsplay

Hero
So, the mirror of opposition.

Mirror of Opposition
This item resembles a normal mirror about 4 feet long and 3 feet wide. It can be hung or placed on a surface and then activated by speaking a command word. The same command word deactivates the mirror. If a creature sees its reflection in the mirror’s surface, an exact duplicate of that creature comes into being. This opposite immediately attacks the original. The duplicate has all the possessions and powers of its original (including magic). Upon the defeat or destruction of either the duplicate or the original, the duplicate and her items disappear completely. The mirror functions up to four times per day.


Apart from using a 2e equivalent to kill the neighborhood D&D bully's demigod, this just seems ripe for abuse.

For instance, if you owned two of these, it seems like you could assassinate nearly anyone, since who could fend off two of themselves, even on a good day?

This is also a good method for dealing with Pun-Pun the Kobold. But it could also be used against comparitively more minor threats, such as Takhisis, Asmodeus, or Gruumsh.

What are the rules for getting someone to look at a mirror, or accidentally looking at one?

You could use it on yourself, then immobilize the duplicate of yourself. You could then steal his items, and while he is contained, make use of two cudgels of St. Cuthbert, or two Swords of Kas. You could expend the charges out of your duplicate's staff of wizardry, or even use his rings of wishes. He also has a mirror of opposition, so you could then turn a duplicate of him onto him once you were ready to dispose of him.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


James McMurray said:
Rocks fall, everybody dies. Or perhaps orbital cows?

In other words, it's meant as a cursed item. If it's treated as a cursed item it works just fine.

It's not listed under cursed items. And it's not really all that expensive. It weighs 45 pounds. And it can be "hung or placed on a surface." To me, it sounds like portable trouble.
 

pawsplay said:
What are the rules for getting someone to look at a mirror, or accidentally looking at one?
The Gaze Attack rules may be a god starting place.

As for limiting its power, I suggest using a very broad definition for the concept of "Defeat":
  • If the duplicate is immobilised, they're defeated and go 'poof', along with all their items.
  • If the original steals the duplicate's ring of wishes and retreats, their retreat signals that the original is defeated, and the duplicate goes 'poof', as does the ring.
  • If for any reason they cannot actively engage in combat with each other to the extent that you'd drop them out of initiative, they're both considered defeated, and the duplicate goes 'poof'.
EDIT: As for their utility against super-powerful foes, any super-powerful foe will know the one surefire way to beat the Mirror: Surrender immediately. The moment you declare defeat, your opponent vanishes.
 
Last edited:

pawsplay said:
It's not listed under cursed items. And it's not really all that expensive. It weighs 45 pounds. And it can be "hung or placed on a surface." To me, it sounds like portable trouble.

Sorry, I didn't go check where they're located in the rules, but every published version of one I've ever seen was part of a trap, not a treasure hoard (unless used to trap the hoard).

It's one of the many things in D&D that if taken to its logical conclusion it becomes trouble, but if played as intended it can be fun. I tend to play those things as intended.
 


lukelightning said:
This is one of those things that should be treated as a plot device, not an actual item.

I find this statement a little hard to understand. What is to prevent someone from plucking this "plot device" off the wall and taking it with them?
 




Remove ads

Top