My Upcoming Campaign Is Starting to Terrify Me

[Jared Rascher]

Pawsplay and fba, I think I am just trying to overthink this before it even gets going. For all I know, I'll have a bunch more people that haven't contacted me in the group, and I'll have a different mix of people than I thought, or things will just flow naturally with everyone once they make up their characters.

 

[The Shaman]

If the Quiet Man is enjoying himself, participates consistently, and isn't cockblocking anyone else's fun, don't worry about him.

High Expectations Girl sounds like someone who actually makes her own fun, a self-motivated player who engages the game-world and the characters therein - my ideal sort of player, actually - so as long as you give her the tools to do so, I'm sure she'll be singing your praises again.