Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="William Ronald" data-source="post: 2907856" data-attributes="member: 426">I think a well done Greyhawk hardcover, in the style of the Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting or Eberron books, would be welcome.  However, I think that there is no way to please all the different aspects of Greyhawk fandom with their different opinions on what should be canon.  I think that as  FR never lasped into no-support and Eberron is fully supported, that they have not developed the degree of fanbase divergence seen in Greyhawk.  (Occassionally, I will see a complaint about the maps between 2nd and 3rd edition, but that is about as far as the divergence between FR fans goes.)Possibly a new Greyhawk hardcover could cover the nations, organizations, and personalities of the setting with some advice on how the setting works.  (Mind you, there is a lot of good material for people to draw on for a hardcover, such as Sean K. Reynold's excellent 2nd edition product the Scarlet Brotherhood.  Even if a person does not use the Greyhawk setting, some of the organizations can be adapted to other settings.  For example, a racist organization similar to the Scarlet Brotherhood can work in many settings -- as can an order of knighthood, such as the Knights of Veluna who protect a specific region and have specific foes.)</blockquote>