New Icons?

[Gez]

Will they be finished given time? They have a rushed, draft feeling the previous didn't.

Of course, given the previous were refined after several polls and discussions and proposals...

 

[Michael Morris]

I'll definately polish them up over time and add new ones, though don't expect any major changes to their sorting order soon.

Note - I've now removed the "legacy" icons so with the sole exception of the poll icon they are all the same size.

 

[RangerWickett]

Y'know, I never pay attention to these icons. I look at thread titles, so icons just sorta distract me.

The ones I really don't like are the animated ones. I know I saw at least one or two that flashed and blinked, and it's really distracting. I think they're too big, and I don't see why we need 50 different icons. We might as well get rid of thread titles, at that rate.

 

[WayneLigon]

Well, I can certainly make them smaller again - but that makes them harder to read. It's a give and take situation. maybe 70x30 was overkill (the older ones are 70x15)

Make them all smaller again. The huge clunky icons just bloat the size of the page and you see fewer items per page.

 

[Michael Morris]

Make them all smaller again. The huge clunky icons just bloat the size of the page and you see fewer items per page.

Wrong. Because this version of vbulletin puts the thread starter's name under the thread title each entry is going to be 30 pixels high REGARDLESS of the size of the post icons or even whether they are present.

 

[Mark]

I suppose they could be a touch smaller, but I think overall they are very well done. Very well done, indeed!

 

[Agamon]

I agree. Nice icons, but a tad on the big side.

 

[WayneLigon]

Wrong. Because this version of vbulletin puts the thread starter's name under the thread title each entry is going to be 30 pixels high REGARDLESS of the size of the post icons or even whether they are present.

D'uh, I see that now. [Emily Litella] Never mind. [/Emily Litella]

 

[pogre]

The ones I really don't like are the animated ones. I know I saw at least one or two that flashed and blinked, and it's really distracting. I think they're too big, and I don't see why we need 50 different icons. We might as well get rid of thread titles, at that rate.

I must agree with this - I really do not like the animated ones at all.

 

[Grazzt]

The ones I really don't like are the animated ones. I know I saw at least one or two that flashed and blinked, and it's really distracting. I think they're too big, and I don't see why we need 50 different icons. We might as well get rid of thread titles, at that rate.

What he said.