Non-Core Class Survivor: Round 3

[Ciaran]

Not the Marshal! Noooo!

And now you want to eliminate the Dragon Shaman? Why all the hating on well-balanced support classes? Man, y'all are wack.

 

[Glyfair]

Ditto.

And, for the third time, You still forgot the Erudite from CPsi. I don't really care about the class one way or the other, but I keep mentioning it for completeness. In fact, I pointed it out before the Scout was even mentioned, IIRC.

I used the Class List to make up my list, and it's not included there as a class, but only as an "alternate Psion", so it doesn't make my list.

 

[Mercule]

I used the Class List to make up my list, and it's not included there as a class, but only as an "alternate Psion", so it doesn't make my list.

Fair enough.

 

[Rystil Arden]

Wilder. Wild mages suck. It'll keep getting my vote until it's gone.

Uh, the Wilder isn't a Wild Mage. It doesn't have any more randomness than a Wizard trying to cast her spells in armour with Arcane Spell Failure. With neither a random surge failure chart nor a caster level forced to vary from lower to higher than the true caster level, the Wilder does not resemble a Wild Mage in the slightest.

 

[Stalker0]

Got to go with the swashbuckler again, after playing with the AE's unfettered it just doesn't seem close.

 

[Presto2112]

I'll leave out classes from books that I have not read, so Psi, Incarnum, Heroes of Horror, and Eberron stuff are out.

Out of the stuff that's left, I'm personally wanting to vote off the oriental flavoured stuff. Buh-bye, Shugenja.

 

[lukelightning]

I renew my quest to eliminate PHBII classes other than knight....[/i]

I voted for the Knight again. I'll keep voting for it till it's gone!

We should make you two do "scissors-paper-rock" over the fate of the knight.

 

[(Psi)SeveredHead]

Uh, the Wilder isn't a Wild Mage. It doesn't have any more randomness than a Wizard trying to cast her spells in armour with Arcane Spell Failure. With neither a random surge failure chart nor a caster level forced to vary from lower to higher than the true caster level, the Wilder does not resemble a Wild Mage in the slightest.

It does seem kind of random when it uses its primary ability, wild surge, which isn't well balanced either. I'll probably vote off the bad psionic classes last, but it and the soulknife are both begging to get kicked off the island.

 

[lukelightning]

... I'm personally wanting to vote off the oriental flavoured stuff.

Just so long as you leave my oriental flavored ramen noodles alone.

 

[Aesthetic Monk]

Voted for wilder (again). I like psionics, but the wilder's limited powers, enervation, etc., just don't work for me, especially when the psion has access to similar abilities.