Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="EOL" data-source="post: 214745" data-attributes="member: 823">This begs the question which system is fantastic?Perhaps D&D isn't realistic enough so you add two kinds of damage and you seperate how difficult it is to hit someone from how difficult it is to damage them.  Next thing you know it's less fun because combat is so much slower.Perhaps you get rid of classes? Well then it takes the DM much longer to create an adventure and they're not as good.  In addition you open up a whole ton of min-max situations which are not easily dealt with.Is D&D fantastic?  Probably not is it to rip-off Churchill "The worst role-playing system except for every other role-playing system?"  Possibly, but I think every time you try and correct one percieved failing you realize that you've created a worse one.</blockquote>