Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="doctorbadwolf" data-source="post: 8805554" data-attributes="member: 6704184">okay I gave perfunctory feedback on the spell list. Basically that their neat little organization idea shouldn't cost classes iconic spells like Bards losing Bane, and that if they keep it, the need to add a list of bonus spells for each class, to cover those gaps without having wizards casting bane. for the rules, I'm not leaving too much detailed feedback. For the most part, just the rating speaks perfectly fine for me. But Hidden and Hide Action are problematic, so I've told them they need to clarify that you can burst from stealth to gank someone from which you were hidden and stab them with advantage, because as written it makes stealth a very very minor benefit. Long Rest I prefer the first UA version of, but I don't care too much bc I'm not strict about Long Rests anyway, you can absolutely sleep for a few hours, spend an hour doing light activity, and then sleep a few more hours, and be fully rested. People are pretty resilient, and I'm just never going to put a bunch of energy into finding every excuse to hinder the PCs. Tools having a normalized price is hilarious. A basic drum costs the same as bagpipes, huh? No thanks. Ritual Casting is the best thing in this UA. Unarmed Strike! The main contender for Ritual Casting's place at the top of the pile. Perfect in every way.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="doctorbadwolf, post: 8805554, member: 6704184"] okay I gave perfunctory feedback on the spell list. Basically that their neat little organization idea shouldn't cost classes iconic spells like Bards losing Bane, and that if they keep it, the need to add a list of bonus spells for each class, to cover those gaps without having wizards casting bane. for the rules, I'm not leaving too much detailed feedback. For the most part, just the rating speaks perfectly fine for me. But Hidden and Hide Action are problematic, so I've told them they need to clarify that you can burst from stealth to gank someone from which you were hidden and stab them with advantage, because as written it makes stealth a very very minor benefit. Long Rest I prefer the first UA version of, but I don't care too much bc I'm not strict about Long Rests anyway, you can absolutely sleep for a few hours, spend an hour doing light activity, and then sleep a few more hours, and be fully rested. People are pretty resilient, and I'm just never going to put a bunch of energy into finding every excuse to hinder the PCs. Tools having a normalized price is hilarious. A basic drum costs the same as bagpipes, huh? No thanks. Ritual Casting is the best thing in this UA. Unarmed Strike! The main contender for Ritual Casting's place at the top of the pile. Perfect in every way. [/QUOTE]

Verification