Scotley
Hero
well three thing i must say:
1: this, as has been pointed out by wd and reinforced by leif, is to honor the late great gary gygax and we would do a gread dishonor to him if we just up and quit.
2:i thing 5 is ok, but as leif mentioned, it never hurts to have a bit more arcane backup
3: Wd asked an important question. It has been mentioned twice that the traps are what are supposed to kill us, not a player drop out...i personallyhave never been through TOH but wds pointed question of :raise dead availability, that is an important factor when it comes to traps. does our cleric have that spell available?
As long as I've got willing players (and live characters

If we were to add a 6th character I would think a support type such as a wizard with a variety of spells or a skill monkey such as bard or ranger would be a good choice. At this point I'm leaning toward going with the current 5.
I don't know what Logan has memorized, but he is capable of casting raise dead. I hope I gave you a raise dead scroll or item in the gear too.