OK, so overnight this thread generated tons of post reports, and at least a couple of (opposing) people decide to use those reports to lecture us mods about stuff and make sarcastic and snide little comments, which is always a great way to make a post report. I had hoped the thread would settle down into an interesting discussion on the nature of playtesting or game design qualifications, but with Gorgoroth being extraordinarily rude to people, and people responding in kind, I guess that's not going to happen. I'm going to close the thread again (seems Umbran was right the first time!)