OT: Is ebay worth it? Selling old DnD stuff

Belen

Legend
Hey all,

I am thinking about selling off my old 1E and 2E materials. I have not made the final decision as yet, but I wanted your opinion.

Has anyone used ebay to sell DnD stuff?
Did you get good prices?

I have hundreds of books, boxed sets, and adventures. This stuff is near and dear to me, but I am getting married in around a year and I need to make room and have money to help pay for the honeymoon etc.

What do you all think?

Dave
 

log in or register to remove this ad

you will never get the price you paid for them.

they are too common an item.

even the price www.acaeum.com lists is way over inflated. only dealers get those prices. and that's only b/c they know how to word their ads.
 

I hope so I am planning on clean up some duplicates I have discovered while reorganizing my shelves. it is a darn shame when I have so much stuff I get duplicates with out realizing it.
ken
Lord knows I buy enough stuff off ebay time to try and sell some
 

IME, as recently as 1999, you used to get much better prices on Ebay - prior to the announcement of the WotC ESD program when E-bay was the ONLY way to find the information/books you were looking for. Now that people can pay $5 for an electronic copy, the demand seems to have abated significantly.

These days stuff seems to go for a half to a quarter of what it used to. I remember D&D Gazetteers (Orcs of Thar, etc.) going for 50-60 dollars. Nowadays they seem to top out at 10-20.

If you're going to trash them anyway, yeah, it's worth it to use E-bay - may as well get SOMETHING out of it. But otherwise, it probably isn't worth it any more.

--The Sigil
 

I haven't had too many problems with E-Bay. Having said that, unless you're doing bundles with low starting prices of selling material that's really old and in really good shape, or has some other factor that limits the replication factor (i.e. I sold a copy of the Dune RPG in mint shape and made some good money) then the only way to think of this is getting some money that you wouldn't get by throwing the stuff in the garbage or giving it to a friend, library or other dump source.
 

I don't know about the 1E/2E stuff, but I've had a good experience liquidating some of my d20 collection {shameless plug} More Coming Soon!!!{/shameless plug}.

diaglo said you'd never get what you paid for them. In most cases, he's right. I've had a couple actually bring in more than the cover price, but that's definitely the exception rather than the rule.
 
Last edited:

Also, besides the ESD program (and piracy, presumably), demand for 2E/1E stuff has gone down a lot since 3E/d20 came out.

In most cases, expect to make 1/5 or less of the cover price.

There are still some rarities. But even those have been hurt, somewhat.
 

It's already been mentioned, but it bears repeating... There are some things you'll get next to nothing for, and other stuff you'll probably do well on.

Selling the stuff on eBay will bring you more money than if you were to sell the stuff to a dealer. It's a heck of alot more work, though.

Things to maximize your money:

1) Accurate, detailed descriptions.
2) Photos/scans of the items.

(Condition is incredibly important, especially since you're talking about out-of-print stuff, which is - in theory - a collectible. People want to know and see what they're bidding on.)

3) Get as many key words in your title as possible - you want people using the search function to be able to find the item.

4) Make sure you list your shipping price in the description (and DON'T overcharge - a small handling fee is okay, but don't be ridiculous). If someone doesn't tell me what shipping is, I won't bid.
5) Most D&D stuff can be sent Media Rate which is cheaper. You may want to consider Priority Mail because the packing materials for that are free at the Post Office.
6) Shipping info can be found online at www.usps.gov.

7) Unless you absolutely have to, DON'T set a reserve price. I won't bid on those auctions.
8) If you feel you must have a reserve, state what that reserve is in the description.

9) Low opening bids draw people in. High opening bids scare people away.
10) You want to get multiple people bidding on the same item. That's what makes you a profit.
11) People will bid more than they really want to if they get in a "war" with someone over an item.
(If you start with a low price, you're more apt to get multiple bidders. If you start with a high price, you're more likely to get only one bidder. If you start with a high price, make SURE that price is what you're willing to part with the item for, because you will probably only get one bidder - if that.)

12) Do a search for any item you plan to list. If there are a few others up already, don't list yours at that time.

13) Do a search for any item you plan to list, then check the completed auctions for that item. That will give you an IDEA of what that item will sell for.

14) If you sell items in lots, be sure to list everything in the lot. If someone is too lazy to type up an accurate list, I'm not gonna give them my money.

That's all I can think of off the top of my head.
 

trancejeremy said:
Also, besides the ESD program (and piracy, presumably), demand for 2E/1E stuff has gone down a lot since 3E/d20 came out.

In most cases, expect to make 1/5 or less of the cover price.

There are still some rarities. But even those have been hurt, somewhat.

Selling on EBay is a LOT of work. Try trading your stuff at Noble Knight Games

http://www.nobleknightgames.com/

Aaron ( who runs the site ) is a great guy...
 

If any of you grognards have old 1e and pre-1e materials---in particular Greyhawk stuff, OD&D, non-TSR supplements by Gamelords, early Chaosium Glorantha stuff, and especially pre-1990 D&D convention tournaments---I'd be happy to check hear about them and check them out.

If I see stuff I'd like, I'd be happy to make an offer (buy or trade current/3e material) or to point you to other hard-core collectors who will give you good $$$ for your valuable stuff (I can't afford the really good stuff ;) ).

Just drop me an email.
 

Remove ads

Top