[OT] Review my Review

[Darklance]

I just posted my first review on the D20 reviews page and I was wondering if anyone had any comments...not on the product itself but how I reviewed it, understandability etc. Thanks.

My review

 

[Darklance]

El BUMPO!

 

[Nightfall]

Dark, in terms of your review, I have NO problems with it. Your rating however...I dunno. I like the module you chose...but I don't think I'd rate it THAT high. (It IS one of Mike Mearls' better works IMHO.) But in any case, it's objective and well thought out. I'm glad to see that.

 

[Darklance]

Great. Thanks for the response.

 

[Nightfall]

My pleasure Dark. I wish others had helped out.

 

[Upper_Krust]

Hi guys!

I wish others had helped out.

Didn't know you were capable of casting 9th-level Arcane spells mate!?

I enjoyed the review. I haven't seen the product so I can't comment directly in that regard.

Grammar was generally good and I really picked up on your enthusiasm for the work.

Perhaps a larger product (and therefore review) would have been a better showcase for us to judge your review style/credentials...but you should be very happy with what you have there!

Overall I give the review 4 out of 5.

 

[Nightfall]

Hi guys!

Didn't know you were capable of casting 9th-level Arcane spells mate!?

Well not this week no. Btw, did you get a reply from Anthony yet about your R&R2 submissions? I got mine (saying they got it.)

 

[Upper_Krust]

Hi mate!

Btw, did you get a reply from Anthony yet about your R&R2 submissions? I got mine (saying they got it.)

Yes I got it earlier...I still don't hold much hope for any of my submissions though - but 'if you're not in you can't win' I suppose!

Bugger! 1:30am here - I am off to bed; have to be up extra early in case the postman delivers Call of Cthulhu! See you all later!

 

[Darklance]

Hi guys!




Perhaps a larger product (and therefore review) would have been a better showcase for us to judge your review style/credentials...but you should be very happy with what you have there!

Overall I give the review 4 out of 5.

Thanks. I just might do that.

 

[Nightfall]

Just remember to make your Will Save or otherwise, I don't think you'll be liveable.