Heretic of The Seventh Circle
Does that match your experience of the rules in 3.5 and 4e? It certainly doesn’t mine.Sure, but problems sometimes arise when different people have different interpretations. It is only supposed to be a game, but I've seen some people get pretty upset when those differences create problems. Much of that could have been avoided IMO if the rules were more concrete since the DM can always change them.
Anyway, I agree there is no "right", though.