Pirates of the Spanish Main Role Playing Game

[Psion]

Its a dead simple system, and its basically Pirates of the Carribean.

How can you go wrong?

Answer to your question bolded.

 

[Psion]

As Thanee was kind enough to point out, I said "almost universal."

Touche. Nonetheless, it does make the system sound more raved about that I feel it really is. Though it's fans certainly love it. I'm not disputing anyone at their taste, just opining that there are those of us who tried the system and didn't care for it. FWIW.

 

[Asmor]

Touche. Nonetheless, it does make the system sound more raved about that I feel it really is. Though it's fans certainly love it. I'm not disputing anyone at their taste, just opining that there are those of us who tried the system and didn't care for it. FWIW.

I can certainly understand why you don't like it. However, in my experience (i.e. anecdotally), I've met very few people online or IRL who don't like the system (incidentally, my fiancée is one of them who doesn't)