Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Hussar" data-source="post: 7570041" data-attributes="member: 22779">Sigh.&nbsp; Yes, I get it.Now, do you get the fact that there&nbsp; is a complete, explicit, disconnect between the player's stated actions and what's going on in the fiction that is possibly problematic to some people at the table?Why is there this repeating need to characterize the other side of the discussion as unreasonable and judgemental?&nbsp; &quot;Dirty&quot;?&nbsp; That's your words.&nbsp; I've repeatedly stated that whatever floats your boat is fine.&nbsp; It doesn't float mine.&nbsp; Why the incessant need to put words in my mouth instead of simply accepting that people have differing tastes?At the end of the day, why do you possibly care how I play?&nbsp; Would I enjoy a group where everyone does the most advantageous thing, no, I would not.&nbsp; To me, I value characterization and being in character more than, what I see as simply trying to beat every scenario.&nbsp; Actions that are out of character and inconsistent are not fun for me.&nbsp; I get that other people play differently.&nbsp; Fine and dandy.&nbsp; I don't think in this entire thread I've made a single value judgement on those that play that way.&nbsp; It's not to my taste, but that doesn't make it bad.&nbsp; Just not to my taste.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Hussar, post: 7570041, member: 22779"] Sigh. Yes, I get it. Now, do you get the fact that there is a complete, explicit, disconnect between the player's stated actions and what's going on in the fiction that is possibly problematic to some people at the table? Why is there this repeating need to characterize the other side of the discussion as unreasonable and judgemental? "Dirty"? That's your words. I've repeatedly stated that whatever floats your boat is fine. It doesn't float mine. Why the incessant need to put words in my mouth instead of simply accepting that people have differing tastes? At the end of the day, why do you possibly care how I play? Would I enjoy a group where everyone does the most advantageous thing, no, I would not. To me, I value characterization and being in character more than, what I see as simply trying to beat every scenario. Actions that are out of character and inconsistent are not fun for me. I get that other people play differently. Fine and dandy. I don't think in this entire thread I've made a single value judgement on those that play that way. It's not to my taste, but that doesn't make it bad. Just not to my taste. [/QUOTE]

Verification