Possible cover designs for Adventure 8 - Diaspora; feedback requested

[Ajar]

Looks like it's falling to me to be the odd man out. I prefer the second. :/

Agreed, I think the bottom one is closer to the style of the other covers.

 

[eamon]

I prefer the top one, and I think it's because it makes the foreground feel a little less cut-and pasted on. The extra gradient and finer detail make the contrast with the foreground less jarring.

 

[Dezhem]

I prefer the cover of the first one, but the less spoiler content of the back cover of the second.