Artamo
Explorer
Wish Bernie Wrightson were still alive to draw such a thing - that would’ve been a horror geek’s dream come true!Give me a Tales from the Crypt-style limited cover on the Ravenloft anthology and you've got an insta-buy from me.
Wish Bernie Wrightson were still alive to draw such a thing - that would’ve been a horror geek’s dream come true!Give me a Tales from the Crypt-style limited cover on the Ravenloft anthology and you've got an insta-buy from me.
Or fill a dump truck with dollar bills and get Mike Mignola to do it.Wish Bernie Wrightson were still alive to draw such a thing - that would’ve been a horror geek’s dream come true!
Technically, domains hadn’t been invented when the module was written, so it hadn’t been established that he couldn’t do that.What if Strahd suddenly appeared in another Ravenloft domain, something he shouldn’t be able to do, and…wait a minute…is he actually a good guy?
That's the biggest hit against Gryphon Hill; it was written before the Ravenloft setting was a thing and unlike I6, is very hard to retcon into the setting (classic or modern) because it breaks so many fundamental setting rules.Technically, domains hadn’t been invented when the module was written, so it hadn’t been established that he couldn’t do that.
I would love to see a book similar to a 5e14 adventure like Tomb of A; Dragon Heist; or Storm King - that's part adventure and part gazeteer that covers Thay as well as other areas of Faerun.Weighing in:
- They hinted at a Red Wizards of Thay campaign a couple years back and I suspect it might materialize this year now that the updated FR books are out. I almost wonder if the Arcane class UA might be material that shows up in here. (These usually fall in September.)
STK was nothing like Against the Giants. That said, AtG was reprinted in Yawning Portal. So really just Descent into Depths, Kuo-Toa, Vault of Drow, and QoDWPits.Given what an odd ending that was to the original saga -- Lolth was the enemy of the drow cult who were behind the giant invasion -- I'd love to see the entire saga get a through rewrite to make it more coherent and more tightly plotted and include other giant and Underdark groups.
I don't own Storm King's Thunder, but a remake of Queen of the Spiders would also need to differentiate itself from that as much as possible.
Breaking the rules makes for a good story, especially when the rules are well known. The dark powers aren’t omnipotent. Vecna got out, so has Azlin. Strahd managing to psychically project his influence (hay, we have psionics now) into another domain isn’t too much of a stretch, especially if you stay true to the Gothic genre and keep the details vague and dreamlike.That's the biggest hit against Gryphon Hill; it was written before the Ravenloft setting was a thing and unlike I6, is very hard to retcon into the setting (classic or modern) because it breaks so many fundamental setting rules.
As a historical document, it's fascinating. As a general module, it's serviceable but not great, but as a piece of Ravenloft continuity, it's an abysmal dumpster fire. Clearly an example of the whole being less than the sum of it's parts.
The problem is that Gryphon Hill only works as a prequel, not sequel, to Curse of Strahd. Even the "official" explanation of it (In the War with Azalin) places the events before Mordent is a domain and places the events as the reason Mordent is absorbed into the Mists. It also absolutely makes it's domain lord, Godfrey, a bit player at best.Breaking the rules makes for a good story, especially when the rules are well known. The dark powers aren’t omnipotent. Vecna got out, so has Azlin. Strahd managing to psychically project his influence (hay, we have psionics now) into another domain isn’t too much of a stretch, especially if you stay true to the Gothic genre and keep the details vague and dreamlike.
The problem is that Gryphon Hill only works as a prequel, not sequel, to Curse of Strahd. Even the "official" explanation of it (In the War with Azalin) places the events before Mordent is a domain and places the events as the reason Mordent is absorbed into the Mists. It also absolutely makes it's domain lord, Godfrey, a bit player at best.