I was right! We did get a D&D announcement today.
Unfortunately it’s for the Fan Fest nights at Universal
Unfortunately it’s for the Fan Fest nights at Universal
As someone who did play the G series as they came out when I was, in fact, 12 -- who cares?I think with some of them you a in a bit of a Ship of Theseus situation. How much can you change and have it still feel like that classic adventure you played when you were 12?
And that's basically what I'm advocating: Let Yawning Portal go out of print and bring back the new adventures in more expanded format. (The original could/should still be sold on digital platforms, for those who want it.)I think it's significant that there were more changes in the Infinite Staircase adventures - published when 5e has established it's own fanbase, independent of the nostalgia of the older generations.
Yep, I've got it. I just felt the pressure to keep zipping along with the adventure -- which has multiple ticking clock elements -- rather than letting the player characters play tourist, which they really wanted to do.There is an expansion on DMG by the original authors that describes San Citlan in more detail, including a big map of the city.
Why? Shorn of their nostalgia, most of them simply aren’t very good. How would you turn White Plume Mountain into anything other than a silly fun house? And what would be the point? You might recycle the Giants adventures for a Decent Into The Depths campaign book, but there is no point in redoing the whole of YP.And that's basically what I'm advocating: Let Yawning Portal go out of print and bring back the new adventures in more expanded format
Yep, I've got it. I just felt the pressure to keep zipping along with the adventure -- which has multiple ticking clock elements -- rather than letting the player characters play tourist, which they really wanted to do.
I think it's unlikely, but would love to see San Citlan have its own campaign adventure and really expand the setting beyond what we see in Journeys Through and the Journeys Beyond PDF. It's basically Mexican Eberron, which isn't immediately obvious without the PDF, but which is very cool once you realize what you're dealing with.
I did not know that! Now I'm even more annoyed that I can't do a la carte purchases from D&D Beyond. (The rest of the book would be wasted on me, as it's 100% not what I was hoping for when the title was first announced.)Not a campaign adventure, but FWIW Shard of the Accursed in Keys from the Golden Vault is set in the mountains south of San Citlan.
That's why I repeatedly said not all of the adventures should be brought forward.Why? Shorn of their nostalgia, most of them simply aren’t very good.
Tsojcanth was brought forward strictly for the Tasha connection. It was a very ordinary adventure at the time, most notable for having a defacto mini-Monster Manual included with it, ahead of Monster Manual II being published.The adventures in Infinite Staircase were selected because they have something to offer now.
Touches my OAR collection, including Castle Amber.And there is still Castle Amber and a bunch of other classic adventures that stand up better than the YP selection that have yet to be touched.
Given the Mystic Subclasses UA that just dropped, I'm leaning towards a magic-focused rules expansion being a near certainty.
- I'm not sure we are going to get a dedicated rules expansion, but it is possible that's where the Arcane subclasses from the UA will go. If there's a fifth book, that's what I'd bet on.