Prometheus [Spoilers]

.

For me, "slip the new life form into somebody's drink" doesn't seem remotely plausible as the first idea that a desperate man would come up with. It seems to me to be a dumb idea, and that he could have had much better ideas.
the crew is pretty much in two camps, I noticed. Those hired by Weyland directly (the bad guys), and the "good guys" who are unaware of Weyland's agenda. If you've been paid (or created!) by a man with unlimited resources and an obsession with immortality, I can imagine ethics are not a high priority. I do agree that the so-called scientists acted frustratingly stupid at times, but it wasn't quite a deal-breaker for me. My first thought when David spiked the drink was not "what? No HAZMAT training!?" but "uh-oh. The android is evil."
 

log in or register to remove this ad


My main complaints are the scientific irrationality of it. Why would you think that introducing a drop of weird goo into the drink of a human would have any real reaction, other than perhaps causing the guy to die of an infection? What would that accomplish?

You have advanced medical and biological exam equipment on the ship. Use that. Don't just randomly toss goo into someone's food. Nothing had yet occurred that would rationally have made the characters think "this might be some sort of transgenic super-science goo that will turn our archaeologist buddy into a monster."

Also, especially after a character hangs a lampshade on "Darwinian evolution" making the theory of "Engineers created humanity, and happened to have a genome that makes perfect sense as part of earth biodiversity, despite coming from another planet" very unlikely, I just couldn't help but lower my opinion of the movie.

I dunno, maybe in the sequel we'll learn that 2 million years ago another alien species came to earth, picked up some humans, and developed the Engineers, who eventually got high tech gizmos of their own and eventually decided to annihilate the crucible of humanity. I could buy that. Crazy religious zealots think "those humans suck; we're spacemen now, so we have to kill earthmen so we are not corrupted."

Still doesn't make sense why you'd use weird, thermodynamics-defying mutants to do it, instead of good old fashioned lasers and missiles and stuff.
 

My main complaints are the scientific irrationality of it. Why would you think that introducing a drop of weird goo into the drink of a human would have any real reaction, other than perhaps causing the guy to die of an infection? What would that accomplish?

You have advanced medical and biological exam equipment on the ship. Use that. Don't just randomly toss goo into someone's food. Nothing had yet occurred that would rationally have made the characters think "this might be some sort of transgenic super-science goo that will turn our archaeologist buddy into a monster."

Exactly. It's a completely weird and dumb thing to suddenly decide to do. Why not decide to to cartwheels around it instead? Or read it a bedtime story? Or set fire to it? Or a million other totally bizarre non-sequiter things you could think of to do as the first thing to do when fidning an alien life form. Slipping it into somebody's drink? Really?
 

Just got back from the seeing the movie with my wife.

Her observation: ace bandages don't make good underwear.

It does look like the crew got hit with a bucket of stupid.

When you first arrive at a new planet, you launch satellites to scan it for weather, life, and structures. You don't just cruise on down and cast about looking for whatever pops out.

You don't beam down to the planet without weapons. Even Captain Picard knows that, and he's way more enlightened about humanity not being all warlike and crap.

When the android is behind the group aways poking at the wall and suddenly holograms pop up, don't you think you should look at what he did? Let alone when he starts tapping on the pad at the door. Clearly it's time for a WTF talk with the android about showing initiative. Milk-blooded bastard, meet baseball bat.

3 adults looking at art on the walls can't keep track of the android with pokey paws in the same room who is clearly futzing with the jars just like you told him not to.

the geologist who launched the scanner pods for mapping would not have gotten lost.

the geologists who got scared by the giant dead bodies would have been doubly freaked by moving goo and penisnakes. They would have waited as close to the entrance of the structure as possible so they could get back to the ship quickly and avoid finding anything worse.

When you are an evil android (as I had to point out during the intro that he would be evil), the scientific method doesn't go out the window. You scan wierd black goo with tools BEFORE you put it into a human's beverage.

When you get sick, and notice kinky tentacles in your eye, you go see the doctor, not lie about it. You are already pretty screwed up and aren't just going to get over it like a cold. After all, you have TENTACLES in your eye.

Despite the androgenyzing ace bandage undies, Charlize still has nipples.

It would make more sense to keep grampa in bed until first contact or super science is actually found to use on him, rather than so he can be there to pester the alien right after waking him up from his nap. Because seriously, your problems are less important after a long nap than peeing, food, and killing the jerk who woke me up.

Being the last 2 humans on the planet, what are the odds that the alien spaceship is going to come down right by you AND roll after you, and fall over on top of you. I'd say 50/50. Because every other time a drop a penny, it rolls toward me and then falls over onto my foot.

Having just crashed back onto the planet after having my ship rammed, and surviving the fall, and still not having had a good pee, why chase after the human, instead of heading for a back-up site's ship. Then you could take off, and nuker her from orbit, which has long been acknowledged as the best way to take care of pesky species problems.
 



Why was Charlize's character even in the film? If you took out her scenes, it doesn't look like anything would change.

Her character was meant to parallel Elizabeth Shaw's with the daddy/'Father' issues, but it was just badly handled like so many of the film's ideas.
 

Which prop and how much cash did you drop on it??

Custom made alien costume, it's on a dummy currently.

And I spent too much on it. Did win a local costume contest with it though a year or two ago, and scared the piss out of kids in the neighborhood with it. :D

DSC00454.jpg
 
Last edited:

I guess I missed something about Charlize. Why couldn't she use the med-pod?
The medpod was only set up for men.

I forget the exact word used, but I got the impression it wasn't just a password issue. The thing just didn't do female troubles. Broken arm, fine. Uterine cancer, tough luck. Ergo, Shaw can't do a abortion or caesarian; she has to undergo abdominal surgery to remove a foreign object.
 

Remove ads

Top