Quintessential Fighter/Arms & Armor/Sword & Fist: What books are you using?

[novyet]

I use sword and fist in my campaign. I don't have arms and armor so I can't voice an opinion on that, but I do have the quintessential fighter, and I'll say this I like the OMCS, the prestige classes, and the feats. The fighting styles are a cool concept, but not one I'd use in my campaign. The new weapons however is never coming within 10' of my campaign.(much like the mercurial weapons from s&f) Most of them are simply better versions of existing weapons and they're still martial. Like the flamberge or the flametongue, or that silly spider knife.(19-20 x3 for a martial weapon?!) A few are useful like the simple weapons or the exotics, but for the most part I'm not going to use the book. I don't feel disappointed in the book mind you, but it's definitely a lot higher powered than I prefer. Of course YMMV, so form your own opinions.

 

[dagger]

I pretty much use some out of all 3 products...

 

[Corinth]

I'll never use TQF, and I'm not keen on Arms & Armor either. I do use Sword & Fist, but only that which I need to get what I want; the rest can sit and spin for all I care.