Recruiting Poll Part II! Specific Adventures in Tymadeau and Scandaj

[unleashed]

Okay, this time I voted and it wasn't for all eight choices... though I was sorely tempted to, I settled for my five favourites.

As to the remarks of generic or uninspiring to the posted adventures I've seen, I can say from experience that they likely won't turn out as you expect. After all, if Rystil gives everything away up front, it'd spoil the finish.

 

[Lord_Raven88]

Pirates and the Lost Library got my votes

 

[Fenris]

Without an all button I really had to narrow down choices. I voted for Musketeers and the Tralg Empire. But truely they all sound great.

 

[Ivellious]

Warlords and the Library got my vote Sadly it doesn't look like I'll get it though cause everyone like musketeers

 

[Rystil Arden]

Well, it's not that I was expecting something that didn't show up, it's just that the Scandaj adventures seem somewhat... "generic D&D"-ish. Which is not really a bad thing, it's just that they do not really possess the Norse flavor I had hoped to see in the setting, and do not grab me as strongly as the two adventures I voted for. But, to be honest, I can't really come up with any particularly Norse-themed adventures as examples of what I was thinking of... so I suppose I don't have much of a right to say anything.

unleashed is correct to say that most of the ones that seemed generic had Norse stuff I wasn't giving away up front. After all, imagine I was trying to do Gothic Horror and I gave this adventure:

Secret of the Vampire--People have been disappearing in the town of Nosferisburg, but no one knows why. The answer is that the local count is a vampire. Join the team to solve this perplexing mystery!

 

[pallandrome]

Join the team to solve this perplexing mystery!

I'll do it for a scooby snack!

 

[stonegod]

if I was in an RA game, I think I'd go for Library, Pirates, then Musketeers (with Knights a bit fourth). But I'm not. Yet. Maybe.

 

[Rystil Arden]

if I was in an RA game, I think I'd go for Library, Pirates, then Musketeers (with Knights a bit fourth). But I'm not. Yet. Maybe.

Actually, I'm running this poll before making the new game (see Part I which has fallen a bit now that the new one is up)

 

[Rystil Arden]

Hmm...interesting. Well, I don't want to pick the game based solely on results here (since if 10 people like Pirates most and they all picked Pirates and Musketeers, they would be sealing their doom), so after we get a few more votes, I'll put up a final one with the games that get enough votes only.

 

[Rystil Arden]

One last bump, though it seems highly unlikely that anything except Musketeers, Pirates, or Lost Library will make the cut-off anyway, even if we get more votes like we had in the first round. Actually, I'll just make the final poll and then ask for a write-in if we get a sudden surge in this poll.