Round 9 Is Over

[Matt Black]

EXOTIC WEAPON PROFICIENCY - Exotic weapons are very rarely good enough to be worth a whole feat to be able to use

GREATER TWO WEAPON FIGHTING - Two weapon fighting is too expensive as is. Yet another feat to be able to do it only slightly better? Blah!

 

[Nifelhein]

Natural Spell
Quick Draw

Cause you want more from a single feat.

 

[I'm A Banana]

I just got here, so can someone explain how the H-E-Double-Hockey-Sticks the mighty POWER ATTACK, the no brainer cornerstone feat of every two-handed weapon user, got voted off?

Obviously because it wasn't a survivor.

I'm a survivor (what),
I'm not gonna give up (what),
I'm not gon' stop (what),
I'm gonna work harder (what),
I'm a survivor (what),
I'm gonna make it (what),
I will survive (what),
Keep on survivin' (what),
I'm a survivor (what),
I'm not gonna give up (what),
I'm not gon' stop (what),
I'm gonna work harder (what),
I'm a survivor (what),
I'm gonna make it (what),
I will survive (what),
Keep on survivin' (what).

Seriously, though, it's limited to one category of warrior and it got immunity last round, raising the hackles of everyone who thought that it was overrated.

 

[Kaji]

Cleave [general]
Craft Magic Arms And Armor [item Creation]

 

[Crothian]

I just got here, so can someone explain how the H-E-Double-Hockey-Sticks the mighty POWER ATTACK, the no brainer cornerstone feat of every two-handed weapon user, got voted off?

not all feats that sucky get voted off, some of them are just a little too good. A no brainer feat is a little too good. Besides, way to much combat in the game anyway.

 

[Ridley's Cohort]

Sorry, I am late to the party. The standard is what are the best designed feats? Or what feats we "like" for whatever reason?

 

[I'm A Banana]

Seems like a popularity contest to me!

 

[LightPhoenix]

Natural Spell, Craft Wonderous Item

Even though both have received enough votes to be gone already, I think, I'm voting for these too. The first shouldn't be a feat, as I've already argued, and the latter is much too general... and I hate item creation.

 

[Ion]

EXTEND SPELL [METAMAGIC]
GREATER TWO WEAPON FIGHTING [GENERAL]

These feats don't do anything.

Extend spell doesn't make short spells last long enough, and long spells already last long enough that they dont need to be extended

Greater two weapon - sheesh when going up a feat chain, you are trying to get to BETTER feats, not one that does LESS than the feat before it in the chain.
Improved Two weapon = 1 extra attack at -7 (at best)
Greater Two weapon = 1 extra attack at -12 (again at best)

you convinced me. I vote for them too!

 

[Heathen72]

Sorry, I am late to the party. The standard is what are the best designed feats? Or what feats we "like" for whatever reason?

Hi Ridley - the criteria for elimination is yours to choose.
You can find the original post here

Oh and this round is over - next round up, soon.