Patryn of Elvenshae
First Post
I hope you take this criticism in the spirit it's intended! 
I really, really don't like the original ad.
It reminds me of the RIFTS ads that used to be in Dragon. While the ad was chock-full of good reasons to use RIFTS, the ad itself looked unpolished and unprofessional. While it certainly doesn't need to be some sort of multimillion dollar, slick presentation, it should look clean.
TRW's edit is better, but it still looks like a garage-band flyer (not that there's anything wrong with that, if it's the aesthetic you're looking for).
Where is this ad going to be run?

I really, really don't like the original ad.
It reminds me of the RIFTS ads that used to be in Dragon. While the ad was chock-full of good reasons to use RIFTS, the ad itself looked unpolished and unprofessional. While it certainly doesn't need to be some sort of multimillion dollar, slick presentation, it should look clean.
TRW's edit is better, but it still looks like a garage-band flyer (not that there's anything wrong with that, if it's the aesthetic you're looking for).
Where is this ad going to be run?